A forum to discuss any topic pertaining to the MLB. Topics range from game threads to the obscure.

Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 26th, 2010, 11:42 am

SAN FRANCISCO -- Baseball's playoffs could be expanding in two years.

The new head of the players' union says his members are open to adding more wild-card teams for 2012 and possibly extending the division series to a best-of-seven.

Union head Michael Weiner says it's also possible players would agree to cutting the regular season from 162 games, but that's more problematic because it would cost teams revenue.

"There is sentiment among a substantial segment of the players to consider expanding the playoffs," Weiner said Monday in an interview with The Associated Press ahead of his first World Series since replacing Donald Fehr as union head.

Eight of 30 baseball teams make the playoffs under the format that began in 1995, a year later than intended because of a strike that wiped out the postseason in '94.

Baseball commissioner Bud Selig appears to be increasingly in favor of proposing more playoff teams during collective bargaining with the union next year, which will determine the postseason format for 2012 and beyond.

"We have less teams than any other sport," he said last month. "We certainly haven't abused anything."

In the NFL, 12 of 32 teams make the playoffs. In the NBA and NHL, 16 of 30 teams advance to the postseason.

The first-round series have been best-of-five since they began. It's possible they could follow the path of the league championship series, which began as best-of-five in 1969, then expanded to best-of-seven in 1985.

"There are some players who have expressed an interest in that, as well," Weiner said. "Obviously, you've got to look at everything together. But I think we can have a very healthy discussion with the commissioner's office when bargaining begins about these issues."

Weiner said the union likely would generate a consensus on its playoff stance during its annual executive board meeting in December. Bargaining is likely to start in the first half of the year on the labor contract to replace the one expiring on Dec. 11, 2011.

Only minor tinkering with the playoffs is possible for next October.

"We've been talking about a revised schedule in 2011 that would be a compressed schedule for postseason play," he said. "The structure for playoffs in 2011 will be the same as it's been throughout this contract."

The regular season expanded from 154 games to 162 in the American League in 1961 and the National League a year later, when each of those circuits went from eight to 10 teams.

"Certainly some of the players have said either we should shorten the regular season because the regular season's too long, or we should shorten the regular season to accommodate expanded postseason," Weiner said, adding that would have "revenue implications for the industry."

"That is one of the ideas that they are kicking around. But having said that, we understand that a proposal to reduce the length of the regular season will be viewed one way by the owners as opposed to a proposal to expand or modify the structure of the postseason."

Not all players are in favor of a longer postseason.

"Personally, I like the system the way it is," San Francisco Giants outfielder Aaron Rowand said as he prepared for Wednesday night's World Series opener against the Texas Rangers. "I think just the one wild card team from each league. If you're in a division where you've got a team running away with it, it gives all those other teams hope of something to play for throughout the course of the season."

Through 1968, there were no divisions and the team with the best regular-season record in each league advanced to the World Series.

Giants reliever Jeremy Affeldt is concerned that adding wild-card teams or increasing the length of the division series would make a long season even longer.

"If they're going to do that, they need to shorten the season then. That's a lot of games and that's a long time. Even in the playoffs now we're going potentially to Nov. 5," he said. "Sometimes they think we're just robots, but you've got to think of potential injuries. On pitchers, that's a lot of throwing. Position players, some play every game all year. It just takes a toll on the body. If they're going to do that, they've got to think a lot about the ramifications."

On other topics:

• Weiner said the advanced dates for free agency this offseason were a test for future offseasons. "Both sides will have a chance to evaluate them and when we begin bargaining, presumably sometime in the early part of 2011, we'll have a season of that under our belt."

• While the union chose not to pursue collusion grievances following the past two offseasons, "Some players obviously continue to be concerned about how the free-agent market has operated. We're considering additional proposals concerning the free-agent market."

• Players may propose changes to salary arbitration eligibility, which has been basically unchanged since 1990. "Obviously players have seen the Super 2 cutoff become -- to a certain extent it's become predictable," he said. "Other players say independent of that we think it's time to revisit the question of salary arbitration eligibility in general."

• Players hope the September decision by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that the federal government illegally seized the 2003 drug survey test records and samples will be the end of the matter. The government has until December to ask the Supreme Court to review the case. "Obviously we are pleased with what the court did, and we hope this puts an end to the litigation and that would allow the union and the commissioner's office to be able to honor the promise that was made to all the players who were tested in 2003," he said. "I hope we can look back on 2010 and say that was the year that this litigation ended. Obviously, that remains to be seen."

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=5728656
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby cubbiefan009 on Oct 26th, 2010, 12:50 pm

As long as they reduce the regular season, I'm all for it. If they keep 162+ more playoff teams = less interesting.
User avatar
cubbiefan009
Hall of Famer
 
Posts: 18933
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Fan: Cubs

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby The Great Santo on Oct 26th, 2010, 1:59 pm

Terrible idea. The smaller number of teams making it makes the playoff spot mean something. Having a bunch of wildcards would ruin the wildcard race.

And if they don't shorten the season but make the playoffs longer the season will go too long and it already runs way too long as it is. I don't want a WS during thanksgiving.
Scissors cuts paper, paper covers rock, rock crushes lizard, lizard poisons Spock, Spock smashes scissors, scissors decapitates lizard, lizard eats paper, paper disproves Spock, Spock vaporizes rock, and as it always has, rock crushes scissors.
User avatar
The Great Santo
All-Star
 
Posts: 5183
Location: Kenosha, WI

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 26th, 2010, 2:25 pm

That means the Cubs will have a GREATER chance of making the playoffs? Im in for that! Hahahaha.

On a serious note, im against this. What TGS said. It wont mean as much.
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Macha Man on Oct 26th, 2010, 4:24 pm

I wouldn't be against adding 1 or 2 more playoff teams per league. Compare it to other sports, I'd still say getting to the playoffs in the NFL is pretty meaningful, and that's 6 teams making it in. Don't go to 8 like NBA and NHL, because that takes all the meaning out, but especially in the NL, 4 out of 16 is rough

And yes, shorten the regular season if you add playoff teams.
2009 BrewersCubs.com Best Poster of the Year!
User avatar
Macha Man
Hall of Famer
 
Posts: 18401
Location: Neenah, WI
Fan: Brew Crew!

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby The Stache on Oct 26th, 2010, 4:36 pm

Yea, other leagues send half or more than half the teams to the playoffs, yet baseball only gets 8 out of 30? NBA and NHL send 16 out of 30 teams. I wouldn't mind a couple more. 1 more wild card team for each league.
User avatar
The Stache
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 21726
Location: Palatine, IL

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 26th, 2010, 4:46 pm

Cant do bye series in baseball. Thats just stupid. You cant add just 2 teams per league either because of the bye series. If your going to add teams per league its gotta be four more. Which makes it 8/16 and half the league.
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby The Stache on Oct 26th, 2010, 4:53 pm

Indianplaya17 wrote:Cant do bye series in baseball. Thats just stupid. You cant add just 2 teams per league either because of the bye series. If your going to add teams per league its gotta be four more. Which makes it 8/16 and half the league.


Byes would be interesting, but I agree, you cant have byes in which entire series' are played, For 1 game its fine.

So yea, it would be 4 more, making it a total of 12 out of 30. 12 might be pushing it. You dont want teams with below .500 records making the playoffs and your most likely would get that with 12.
User avatar
The Stache
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 21726
Location: Palatine, IL

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Macha Man on Oct 26th, 2010, 5:00 pm

What would be wrong with byes if it was a 3 game series? 6 teams per league, top 2 get a bye, bottom 4 play a best of 3 with no off days.

And stache, if you only had 12 teams in, that would be 6 per league, which means you would most likely have a bye, which you started your post by saying you don't want.
2009 BrewersCubs.com Best Poster of the Year!
User avatar
Macha Man
Hall of Famer
 
Posts: 18401
Location: Neenah, WI
Fan: Brew Crew!

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby The Stache on Oct 26th, 2010, 5:02 pm

Macha Man wrote:What would be wrong with byes if it was a 3 game series? 6 teams per league, top 2 get a bye, bottom 4 play a best of 3 with no off days.

And stache, if you only had 12 teams in, that would be 6 per league, which means you would most likely have a bye, which you started your post by saying you don't want.


:oops:

My bad. Not sure what I was thinking.

Disregard anything Ive said in this thread
User avatar
The Stache
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 21726
Location: Palatine, IL

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 26th, 2010, 5:03 pm

Isn't it 4 per league already? So adding 4 more would make it 8 per league and 16 in the entire MLB.

3 division winners and 5 WC? Thats just absurd, IMO. Winning the division wont matter as much anymore.
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 26th, 2010, 5:05 pm

Macha Man wrote:What would be wrong with byes if it was a 3 game series? 6 teams per league, top 2 get a bye, bottom 4 play a best of 3 with no off days.

And stache, if you only had 12 teams in, that would be 6 per league, which means you would most likely have a bye, which you started your post by saying you don't want.


I remember mentioning this before in another thread but the momentum you carry into the playoffs would be killed. In baseball, i think the momentum and being "HOT" heading into the playoffs plays a big part (i.e- Rockies a few years back)
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby slaket13 on Oct 27th, 2010, 10:07 am

MLB:"we need Boston and la and Chicago to make the playoffs EVERY YEAR."

What the hell? The giants are in the world series and this stupid topic comes up? We should be talking about Wilson, lincecum, Ross, uribe, and posey.
O
"It was about the third or fourth inning. I had a pulled groin and couldn't fuck at the time. She was a very nice girl and asked me what to do with the cum after I came in her mouth. I said don't ask me, I'm no cock-sucker."

--- Mickey Mantle, The All-American Boy
User avatar
slaket13
Most Valuable Player
 
Posts: 12307
Location: Tahoe City, CA
Fan: SF Giants, PACKERS

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Boozer1011 on Oct 27th, 2010, 1:07 pm

TERRIBLE idea. Why would we want a shorter regular season which just means, LESS baseball? No thanks!

3 game series? More bad. The worst team in the game can beat the best team in the game 2 out of 3 times. Playoff series need to be 7 games...even the current 5 game series is too much of a crapshoot.

I don't see 1 good thing about adding more playoff games...unless it means bringing back regularly scheduled double headers.
Boozer1011
Major Leaguer
 
Posts: 1132
Location: Wrigleyville
Fan: Cubs

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Oct 27th, 2010, 3:40 pm

I think making it a 7-7-7 playoff format would be the way to go. No need to add more playoff teams or reducing the # of regular season games. Just add 2 more playoff games. 5-7-7 is kind of odd to me.
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby chiguy79 on Oct 29th, 2010, 2:30 pm

The playoffs are fine the way they are. The wild card addition back in '95 has served it's purpose (keep second place teams interested even if they're way out of the division race). The wild card has essentially become a 4th division. If you add more wild cards it removes the fix it was and takes away the thrill the the wild card originally was intended as. I don't recall any year since it's inception that the wild card wasn't up for grabs going into at least the last week of the season.

As for the playoffs meaning something in other sports, sure additional wild cards work in the NFL becuase it's win or go home, not a series. With basketball or hockey, people don't really pay attention to those sports until it's close to the playoffs. Personally, I equate their playoffs as the regular season becuase half their leagues make the playoffs and teams with losing records can make it in.
User avatar
chiguy79
Major Leaguer
 
Posts: 1663
Location: San Diego, CA
Fan: Cubs

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby Indianplaya17 on Nov 18th, 2010, 11:16 pm

No opposition to expanded playoff plan
Source: Associated Press

ORLANDO, Fla. -- Commissioner Bud Selig's plan to expand baseball's playoffs to 10 teams gained a sense of inevitability after little to no opposition emerged during meetings this week with owners and general managers.

Selig said his special 14-man committee will discuss adding two wild-card teams when it meets Dec. 7 during the winter meetings in nearby Lake Buena Vista.

"We will move ahead, and move ahead pretty quickly," Selig said Thursday after three days of meetings concluded.

A change would have to be approved by owners, who next meet Jan. 12-13 in Paradise Valley, Ariz., and by the players' association, which has said it is open to the extra round. The additional games would also have to be sold to baseball's national television partners and slotted into a crowded schedule that has already pushed the World Series into November in the past two years.

Because baseball's labor contract runs to December 2011, the extra round of playoffs is not likely to start until 2012.

"I'm not going to rule out anything," Selig said. "We'll just proceed and whatever we decide, then we'll just see how fast we can get it done. Once we pass something, I'm always anxious to get it done."

Selig's committee includes managers Tony La Russa, Jim Leyland and Mike Scioscia and former manager Joe Torre.

There would be two wild-card teams in each league, and the wild-card teams would meet to determine which advances to division series with the three first-place teams in each league.

"I think it's definitely worth looking at. I have no problem with that," New York Yankees co-owner Hank Steinbrenner said.

Some would have the new round be best-of-three, and others would have it as a one-game winner-take-all game. The mechanics appear to be at issue more than the concept.

"I pretty much know where all the constituencies are now," Selig said. "Eight is very fair number but so is 10."

Before leaving the meeting, Texas Rangers president Nolan Ryan agreed with the premise that the extra round of playoffs was more a matter of how than if.

"I think that's right," he said.

Baseball doubled its postseason teams to four in 1969 and again to eight in 1995, a year later than intended because of a players' strike that wiped out the 1994 World Series. The vote to add wild cards first took place in September 1993.

"I got ripped and torn apart, and it was pretty bad," Selig said. "If I had defiled motherhood I don't think I could have gotten ripped any more than I did. But now it's fascinating to me. Now they not only like it so much, they want more of it."

The regular-season schedule will almost certainly not be reduced from 162 games.

"There's not much interest in that," he said.

Selig's committee will also discuss whether to expand video review of umpires' calls, which began in August 2008. Its use has been limited to whether potential home runs went over fences and were fair or foul. Selig has said he's against an expansion but willing to consider it.

"There are opinions everywhere on that," he said. "Managers have opinions. General managers have opinions. Owners have opinions. I want to hear them all and look at them."

A consensus also appeared to have developed to propose a slotting system for amateur draft picks and possibly a worldwide draft when collective bargaining begins next year.

While there is a sense that the NFL, NBA and NHL could be headed for labor strife, baseball players and owners anticipate stoppage-free bargaining. Baseball hasn't had a strike or lockout since the 7½-month walkout in 1994-95, and Selig termed current dealings with the union "a constructive relationship."

"Nobody ever could have dreamed we'd have 16 years of labor peace," Selig said. "In American labor history as I someday will say if I ever get around to writing my book, it probably was as a bad a relationship as ever existed."

Selig also said that baseball's revenue will total nearly $7 billion this year, a record. He also said he was declining comment on Anheuser-Busch's lawsuit against the sport, which accuses MLB of improperly trying to back out of an April agreement to extend the company's exclusive sponsorship deal.


http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=5821797
Image
User avatar
Indianplaya17
BrewersCubs.com Legend
 
Posts: 28031
Location: Around these parts
Fan: Chicago teams - Sox

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby McClunger on Nov 19th, 2010, 12:52 am

Dumb idea.
****All-around GREAT GUY****
Knowledgeable Sports Enthusiast

Image
User avatar
McClunger
Hall of Famer
 
Posts: 17414

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby slaket13 on Nov 19th, 2010, 4:13 am

They'll do anything to avoid the giants repeating the next 6-8 years.
"It was about the third or fourth inning. I had a pulled groin and couldn't fuck at the time. She was a very nice girl and asked me what to do with the cum after I came in her mouth. I said don't ask me, I'm no cock-sucker."

--- Mickey Mantle, The All-American Boy
User avatar
slaket13
Most Valuable Player
 
Posts: 12307
Location: Tahoe City, CA
Fan: SF Giants, PACKERS

Re: Playoff Baseball going to be expanded in 2 years?

Postby clarkaddison on Nov 22nd, 2010, 1:29 pm

I wouldn't mind seeing a few more teams added actually. Anything to help the Cubs' odds ;) Am I right?
Guess who's back? I am.
User avatar
clarkaddison
Minor Leaguer
 
Posts: 738
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Fan: Cubs, Bears, Blazers

Next

Return to General MLB

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest