Here it is again. It was a big hit on the espn board when I did it, and I think I have a feel for enough posters on here now to attempt to make relevant choices. If I leave someone out, or you don't like my choice...blow.

Starting lineup:

Rickie Weeks - gobrewers2213: lots of potential, not a lot of results (i.e. karma)

JJ Hardy - me: QB of the team, best looking guy on the roster

Ryan Braun - jpat: most production, leader of the team

Prince Fielder - Fan174: lots of production too, but don't piss him off

Corey Hart - BraunMVP08: contributes a lot, but quietly

Mike Cameron - Tyler67853: has come on strong lately

Bill Hall - BrainDedNed: spotty performance, but still in the lineup

Jason Kendall - UWbrewball: calls a great game (thread)

Rotation:

CC Sabathia - slaket13: what can you say about what he's done since he came here? Amazing.

Ben Sheets - adambr2: still a co-ace

Jeff Suppan - rwilldred27: just when you think he's a waste of money, he really starts to contribute.

Manny Parra - vismund: young guy who could turn out to be great

Dave Bush - medicgary33: he's a thinker

Bullpen:

David Riske - nation11: gotta have him for the stretch run

Guillermo Mota - chukk314: if used sparingly, can do well

Carlos Villanueva - jammin481: very important part of the pen, can go long innings (hence why girls with big boobs date him)

Brian Shouse - thirdstoolin: old fella of the club

Seth McClung - itsmikerivera: using your old name (especially since Kevin Mench is no longer on the team)

Eric Gagne - No Mas Gagne: hee hee

Salomon Torres - trwi7: our shutdown closer

Bench:

Mike Rivera - bobadgers: when he does play, contributes mightily

Craig Counsell - C34halloffame: obvious

Ray Durham - Fire_Yost_Please: could be a starter

Gabe Kapler - tonyei31: another guy who could start on a less deep team, becaue he can still contribute

Laynce Nix - Acragas: why not?

DL:

Yovani Gallardo - biestie: could be our future ace

Russell Branyan - berkshirebull: started out hot, now done

Chris Capuano - brewcrew8: will we ever see him again?

Others who just missed (40-man):

Tony Gwynn Jr. - rkilawee
Joe Dillon - trouty42
Tim Dillard - MatrixCL
Mitch Stetter - wiisamus2
Hernan Iribarren - nfroiland2008

adminnote:Admin Note: RyGuy's classic thread...one of my personal favorites.

RyGuy wrote:mebest looking guy on the roster

Strongly disagree with this part.

Salomon Torres - trwi7: our shutdown closer

Is it requisite that I speak Spanish? Because if it is, we have some problems.

C3 should obviously be starting over Bill hall. Especially because he's got over 1000 more appearances (posts) then Hall.

c3raig wrote:C3 should obviously be starting over Bill hall. Especially because he's got over 1000 more appearances (posts) then Hall.

Yeah, I debated about who would be the starter. I just think of Billy as a starter and C3 as a bench player still. But with posts factored in, probably could have switched it.

Guillermo Mota - chukk314: if used sparingly, can do well

Ironically, this is the same thing his wife said to me the other night :)

RyGuy wrote:
Bill Hall - BrainDedNed: spotty performance, but still in the lineup

I'm honored! The man with the biggest dip in MLB and has been known to frequent the Playboy Club in Vegas. Just like me!

CC Sabathia - slaket13: what can you say about what he's done since he came here? Amazing.

Nice!

Medic wrote:Guillermo Mota - chukk314: if used sparingly, can do well

Ironically, this is the same thing his wife said to me the other night :)

She said that after she calmed down. You weren't there to hear her curse me out for the forty-five minutes prior.

Thanks for putting me in the Bullpen. I wouldn't want to be any place else.

Chukk314 wrote:

Medic wrote:Guillermo Mota - chukk314: if used sparingly, can do well

Ironically, this is the same thing his wife said to me the other night :)

She said that after she calmed down. You weren't there to hear her curse me out for the forty-five minutes prior.

Ah yes. The other side of the story

Good list overall but my question is how the hell is Berkshire NOT TGJ?

T.Y.L.E.R wrote: Good list overall but my question is how the hell is Berkshire NOT TGJ?

Because that would probably give him too much joy in the list. And we dont want to make him that happy, do we?

Medic wrote:

T.Y.L.E.R wrote: Good list overall but my question is how the hell is Berkshire NOT TGJ?

Because that would probably give him too much joy in the list. And we dont want to make him that happy, do we?

I am under the impression Berkshire is high off of life 24/7........

Can we list BerkshireBull as Turnbow?

daubs wrote:Can we list BerkshireBull as Turnbow?

I second this one. Started with alot of promise and hope, then went completely off the deep end.

I Made the roster!! Tony Gwynn Jr. not the best but at least im gettin the sept call up!

Ive been on vacation the last 3 weeks getting married so Ive been gone from the board. Hopefully Ill be back around here a little more for the stretch run....just like Gwynn!

I'm Sheeter! Thanks RyGuy. I'll try to come through down the stretch....

I can live with being Dave Bush.

lol.
good looking list.

Medic wrote:

daubs wrote:Can we list BerkshireBull as Turnbow?

I second this one. Started with alot of promise and hope, then went completely off the deep end.

lol